13 Comments
User's avatar
Jeff Dargis's avatar

Thanks for the video!

Expand full comment
Patrick Nugent's avatar

The Coptic icons have a way of grabbing my attention. The intensity focuses my attention to the Holy, similar to how hearing monks in an old monastery chanting the Divine Office brings me into the presence of the Holy. Maybe I just have a good imagination, but traditional style incons aren't just reminders of holy things. Rather, I feel myself drawn into the presence of something great and mysterious.

Expand full comment
Lee's avatar

Those eyes...

Expand full comment
Prodigal's avatar

Excellent as usual. One point confuses me, though. In one of the captions you point to Islamic influence on decorative embellishments of a fresco. But given that the Islamic conquest of Egypt took place in circa mid 7th century, I wonder if what we see is maybe Coptic language calligraphy. I think Coptic was the last language used in Egypt before Arabic. Or were these embellishments added later than the 5th or 6th centuries? Whatever it is, it does strongly resemble Arabic written in the Kufic script. The arabesque patterns at the top of the arch certainly look Islamic, but its use became common in Islamic arts much later. The Romans used "arabesque-like" patterns long before Christ, though. A good example being on the Ara Pacis altar in Rome. Be that as it may, my list of places to see just got longer :) :)

Expand full comment
Hilary White's avatar

St. Anthony's monastery wasn't built in the 5th century and then left alone. It has art and additions all the way through from its earliest start to the 20th century. The embellishments I'm referring to are the floral curlicues, clearly added later than the figurative frescos.

Coptic language is written using Demotic script added to Greek, and has a very distinctive cursive written form, quite different from Arabic.

Expand full comment
Prodigal's avatar

Thanks. Very interesting.

Expand full comment
Shannon Rose's avatar

Nice!

Expand full comment
i3utm's avatar

Well, just when I thought this is something *only* would know, I see this on Substack. Thank you for highlighting the Desert Fathers. But have you also heard of the "Desert Mothers" as well?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desert_Mothers

Expand full comment
Hilary White's avatar

I was taking them as a collective - all the humans who went to the desert. I'm not interested in bowing to feminism.

Expand full comment
PolycarpGyarados's avatar

Thank you for writing about the Desert Fathers and Coptic Iconography!

Expand full comment
Mark Lajoie of Living Waters's avatar

Grateful always for your thorough well-written treatments!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 14
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Hilary White's avatar

I know they're not Scriptures.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 14
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Hilary White's avatar

Know nothing about it. Is it a Prot thing?

Expand full comment